Comparative Description of the Poles of the Socionic Dichotomy "Merriness-Seriousness"
Русский оригинал этого текста пока недоступен; показан английский перевод.
| ascending values ("merriness") | descending values ("seriousness") |
|---|---|
| youth of the individual or identification of one's life goals with a young, emerging social system (in whose formation the subject participates directly) | old age of the individual or identification of one's life goals with an old social system that has passed the peak of its development (which the subject perceives as a given) |
| a conception of one's world as an open system whose energy resources are seen as unlimited | a conception of one's world as a closed system in which energy resources are felt to be limited and finite |
| a conception that further development follows an ascending trajectory - therefore, everything is done with a certain redundancy, laying the groundwork for future development | a conception that further development can proceed only through the optimization and "calming" of already existing processes - therefore, everything is done economically |
| "subjectivism": the world is an object (a "wild natural environment" requiring development), people are subjects who design and create a new reality, reshape the world to suit themselves, and bring it into conformity with their inner essence - principles, needs, desires | "objectivism": the world is a subject (a "civilized space" requiring people to play by its rules), people are objects who must cultivate and improve themselves in order to adapt better to the laws of objective reality and the needs of society |
| "action at a distance": the individual is interested in the entire world, in what happens far from them in space and time, rather than only here and now (this makes sense because they are oriented toward extensive development and believe that, sooner or later, in one form or another, they or their society will "reach" even the distant parts of the world, and therefore knowledge about these will also prove useful to them) | "local action": the individual is interested only in what they come into direct contact with in their life (because they have already chosen their sphere of activity and style of behavior, integrated into the existing society, and now simply want to live without thinking about anything extraneous) |
| a narrow approach to life is not valued - when there is one sphere in which to apply one's efforts, and everything else is of no interest | erudition, truth-seeking, and calls for a broader view of things are not valued - as creating unnecessary problems |
| people unite, drawn by a shared passion and ideological values, a similar image of the future | people unite because of similarities in their business interests, work, and cultural characteristics - i.e., if they share a common past |
| A fondness for a merry way of life and noisy entertainment, a tendency to laugh loudly in public and in company, and the speed of switching to the informal "you" when getting acquainted are often regarded as basic manifestations of the trait of "merriness" - understood literally. Yet, apart from socionic "merriness" itself, the trait of extraversion plays a very large role here; irrationality, democracy, emotivism, etc., also have some influence. [author's note, 07.2026] | |
| "merriness" is correlated with intuition, and to a lesser extent - with irrationality, extraversion, ethics | "seriousness" is correlated with sensing, and to a lesser extent - with rationality, introversion, logic |
| the most "merry" sociotypes on average are EIE, ILE, IEI | the most "serious" sociotypes on average are ESI, LSE, SLI |
| emotions / ethics | |
| dynamic ethics - emotional redundancy; emotions are intended for no one in particular, but for everyone at once (whoever needs to notice will do so on their own) | static ethics - emotional influence is metered out and directed at specific people, taking their individual characteristics into account (only the intended recipient should notice) |
| emotion as an integral attitude toward a subject or situation (the subject places themselves within the situation, viewing it through the prism of their emotions) | immersion in fine ethical details, the vicissitudes of individual relationships, detached ethical analysis (the subject separates themselves from the object of analysis) |
| emotions have value in themselves; relationships and their manipulation are not ends in themselves, but merely an instrument for realizing one's passions | expressive behavior, if it occurs at all, has no value in itself, but is used as a means, an element of an ethical game, an instrument for establishing and maintaining the desired interpersonal relationships and attachments |
| active influence is exerted on other people's current mood, motivations, and desires; emotional synchronization or desynchronization is achieved (one's own mood improves because other people's mood also improves or deteriorates) | active influence is exerted on how others regard an individual (oneself or a third party) as a set of stable individual characteristics; the individual's moral-ethical image and reputation in other people's eyes are shaped |
| the love-hate dilemma as a programmer of behavior | the good-evil dilemma as a programmer of behavior |
| attraction to an atmosphere of strong passions (more often tragic, mobilizing people for struggle in beta, or more often joyful, life-affirming and inspiring in alpha). Attraction to people with strong emotions. | a striving for an even emotional background (sober and businesslike in gamma or enlightened and calm in delta), suppression of emotional outbursts in oneself and others. Emotional lack of restraint is condemned. A striving for the image of a restrained, well-mannered person. |
| love is understood as an increase in the subjective value of the partner as a person to oneself | love is understood as an increase in one's own subjective value in the partner's eyes |
| unrequited love is considered just as real as mutual love - because what is valued is the emotion experienced itself, rather than the relationship. "True love is that which evokes strong emotions" | love is considered real only when accompanied by a concrete close relationship. "True love is that which has stood the test of time" |
| emotional experiences are seen and experienced as sublime, supremely valuable | emotional experiences in themselves, apart from interaction with the partner as a person, have no significant value |
| from the perspective of the serious, the relationships of the merry are superficial, phantom-like, unreliable (falling apart as soon as they cease to give the subject the desired emotions) | from the perspective of the merry, the emotions of the serious are insincere, artificial, false |
| here, those who cling to relationships in which (in the subject's opinion) there are no feelings and never have been, but in which interaction continues out of a sense of duty or for purely pragmatic reasons, are disrespected and ridiculed | here, it is customary to make ironic remarks about people with strong emotions, to mock pathos and emotional openness and frankness that are inappropriate (in the subject's opinion) |
| logic | |
| static logic - intellectual-logical redundancy - paradigmatic thinking aimed at constructing an integral system that provides understanding of and control over the situation as a whole | dynamic logic - algorithmic thinking aimed at achieving a specific result in the most efficient way (as quickly and at as little cost as possible) |
| they prefer to remake everything "from scratch" as they see fit, even if this reduces current efficiency | they prefer to make local improvements. Understanding what is happening is not so important; the main thing is that it works |
| a conception that knowledge is valuable if it contains information about the interrelationships of existing phenomena as distinct phenomena in space (facilitating the subject's orientation in that space) | a conception that knowledge is valuable if it contains information about a sequence of events through which one phenomenon can be transformed into another (with some specific benefit to the subject derived from this) |
| the truth of knowledge is determined by how consistent it is within the system (improving the interconnection of all concepts in the system, eliminating logical contradictions) | the truth of knowledge is determined by how much it helps to predict the future (to assess the consequences of particular events and actions) |
| intelligence is equated with the ability to maintain order in a system of concepts, to prevent disorder in the world of ideas and things | intelligence is equated with the ability to perform useful actions, achieve results, earn money |
| greater value is placed on generalists who think in terms of systems and are capable of forming a correct conception of any situation on the basis of certain overarching principles | greater value is placed on narrowly specialized experts who have perfected their skills in managing a specific situation and are capable of making correct decisions in their area of competence more quickly and efficiently than others |
| in science, greater value is placed on fundamental research (at the intersection with ideology and public administration); applied knowledge is undervalued | in science, greater value is placed on applied research (at the intersection with business projects); fundamental knowledge is undervalued |
| greater interest in and trust in systems of psychological classification such as socionics | greater interest in and trust in psychological training programs that teach self-improvement for the sake of success in life, and in manipulative techniques such as NLP |
| the management process is implemented by designing a system with a specified internal order of interaction among its elements and monitoring compliance with that order | the management process is implemented by designing sequences of specified actions (including branching sequences: what to do in one case or another) and monitoring compliance with the order in which they are performed |
| the logical constructions of the merry contain subjective elements - conceptual redundancy introduced by their authors that does not correspond to objective reality (from the perspective of the serious) | the activity of the serious is oriented toward "squeezing" the maximum out of current objective reality, but lacks an understanding of the situation as a whole and value for designing the future (from the perspective of the merry) |
| age-related characteristics | |
| Fe and Ti are more important in youth: Fe is needed to attract other people, including sexual partners, and to form a suitable social circle; Ti - to construct an integral picture of the world (to acquire knowledge that is not yet specialized and is, to a significant extent, detached from practice) | Fi and Te are more important at an older age: Fi is needed to preserve existing relationships (whose value only increases with age, since establishing new ones becomes ever more difficult); Te - to be successful in one's chosen narrow sphere of activity (accumulating professional knowledge and skills) |
| a romantic view of the events of one's life, more characteristic of youth | a pragmatic view of the events of one's life, more characteristic of maturity |
| typical shifts (distortions) of meaning | |
| translation Te⇒Fe: a person's objective value to others is explained not through the benefit brought by their activity, but through the mood they create for those around them | translation Fe⇒Te: joy in life, and indeed any emotions, are reduced to the amount of benefit created by a person, measured in monetary terms |
| translation Fi⇒Ti: people's individual characteristics, the values in their lives, and the intimate content of their relationships with those close to them are reduced to their positions in a certain system of ranks and classes | translation Ti⇒Fi: a person's adherence to particular ideological views and logical judgments is explained through their individual personality characteristics |
| the essence of the conflict between orthogonal functions | |
| Fe strives to make global reality subjectively pleasant for itself, to embellish it, to create an emotionally rich atmosphere - festive, romantic, or dramatic, while Te perceives such actions as an objectively pointless waste of resources (time, money) | Te strives to optimize reality, rationalize everything, and remove "useless embellishments", whereas Fe perceives this as "drying out" and "hollowing out" reality, depriving life of its subjective meaning and Fe itself of the means of influencing other people |
| Ti strives to bring order to interpersonal relationships, to bring them into conformity with a system of general formal rules, while Fi perceives this as manifestations of totalitarianism, a threat to personal confidentiality and private life | Fi strives to resolve everything privately and informally, while Ti perceives this as introducing "noise" into the social environment, creating difficulties for formal management and cognition, and leading to the proliferation of corruption |
| combinations with other strong traits | |
| questim intuition - redundant, departing from customary conceptions of the world. It seeks and invents what is fundamentally new (in the process of which ideas undergo an ascending increase in complexity); it shapes the group's distinctive worldview and fundamental ideological differences | declatim intuition - strives not to invent something new, but to find points of contact between already existing ideas; it combines and compiles ideas, adapting them to current conditions (in the process of which they are simplified), and shapes group consensus and cultural norms |
| declatim sensing - redundant in the sense that it strives for natural simplicity and a natural bodily norm optimal for survival under any conditions (which particular conditions is not known in advance) | questim sensing - trains special, unusual bodily characteristics and skills useful for work of a particular, narrowly specialized kind (which kind is already known) |
| the extraverted behavioral program is aimed at emotionally "stirring up" a wide circle of people, inflaming passions, and "pulling" the desired people out of their small local worlds in order to involve them in one's global undertakings (Fe displaces Fi) | the extraverted behavioral program is associated with business initiative that "tests the strength" of any systems of formal rules in order to find weak points in them, circumvent these systems, replace systems of formal relationships with informal ones, and profit from this (Te displaces Ti) |
| the introverted behavioral program is oriented toward finding and creating an order of life arranged so perfectly that it will no longer need to be remade, leaving only the need to live according to its rules (this often leads to ideas of a global utopia, a society that is totalitarian in one sense or another) (Ti displaces Te) | the introverted behavioral program is oriented toward creating a system of close, personalized relationships - emotionally closed in upon themselves in such a way that no outsider will any longer be able to penetrate them (the idyll of a small, close-knit world "only for one's own") (Fi displaces Fe) |
| social (rational) behavior is guided by internal principles - systems of rules by which the subject lives and which they wish to introduce into the surrounding world | social (rational) behavior is guided by social responsibility - a system of moral-ethical norms adopted from outside |
| (irrational) instincts are oriented toward biological survival. In a situation where the choice is between fulfilling one's duty to other people and self-realization, the latter is chosen, and this is considered normal | (irrational) instincts are oriented toward social success. In a situation where the choice is between maintaining adherence to an established system of views on life and achieving success (financial and reputational), the latter is chosen, and this is considered normal |
| judiciousness is combined with democracy - people's goodwill toward one another is individual in character and associated with personal liking - as a result, a society with high internal diversity is formed, containing many potential points of future growth and development (Alpha) | judiciousness is combined with aristocracy - people's goodwill toward one another is expressed through the prism of general ethical rules, tact, and political correctness - as a result, everything radical is rejected, thereby stabilizing society and making it comfortable for everyone, but at the same time also depriving it of possible future development (Delta) |
| decisiveness is combined with aristocracy - there is a power struggle, a war of hierarchically organized groups, to win which the groups inevitably initiate processes of social stratification and increasing complexity within themselves (and their selection promotes the social progress of society as a whole) (Beta) | decisiveness is combined with democracy - there is competition among individual subjects, leading to optimization of the functioning of social institutions, but also to the gradual erosion and destruction in society of everything that is excessively complex, provides no immediate benefit, yet requires resources for its maintenance, ultimately giving rise to regression of the social structure (Gamma) |
Other materials (from the same period) on this topic:
- Properties of Introverted Logic and Their Genesis (V. L. Talanov, 2010) - including the article section “On the Properties That Most Strongly Distinguish Introverted and Extraverted Logical Types”
- EXTRAVERTED ETHICS or INTROVERTED ETHICS?
- on the semantics of the Fe and Fi functions