In What Way Socionics Is Better Compared with MBTI and the BIG FIVE
V. Talanov has written more than once about how socionic typology, by its origin and formation (that is - its genesis), differs fundamentally both from the MBTI system and from the BIG FIVE system.
MBTI was rigidly tied to its questionnaire from the very beginning, and therefore ignored and discarded any personality factors not provided for by the questionnaire.
The BIG FIVE was developed as a factorization of linguistic culture. However, linguistic culture reflects far from everything and not fully, and far from proportionally in terms of significance, those psychological features that are actually important and taken into account in the direct interaction of people. This is so because linguistic culture focuses only on socially significant factors – whereas in the individual interaction of people a multitude of other factors also work and are taken into account.
Socionics, by contrast, unlike these two models, developed as an oral empirical tradition, one moreover interested not so much in trait-factors as in the properties of supra-trait formations – functions and integral types, which in the oral tradition were almost not tied to the basic traits at all, and therefore it naturally absorbed into the properties of its types absolutely all independent psychological personality properties that are at all significant for the interaction of people. That is, in the course of its oral development socionics wrote into the properties of its sociotypes many more independent psychological factor-traits than those four on which the MBTI system stopped forever. It is precisely for this reason that real socionic typology (real - that is, by no means reducible to model A or to descriptions from selected theorists, but instead - reflected in the averaged notions of the socionic mass about the properties of the 16 sociotypes) turns out to be, in its factor content, much richer and much more psychologically adequate, both in comparison with the MBTI system and in comparison with the BIG FIVE system.
To reveal all this richness, it only remains to study this real factor picture, fixed in the averaged mass notions about the properties of the types. Which is what Viktor Talanov did with the help of questionnaire studies. As a result, it turned out that present (encoded) in the sociotypes are not only the four “Jungian” factors of MBTI, but – suddenly - also absolutely all the factors of the BIG FIVE and HEXACO systems, as well as several more significant psychological personality factors, quite meaningful in their content, which had not been described in the psychological literature at all before, although, admittedly, they had already earlier found partial reflection either in the classifications of a number of psychological accentuations and cognitive styles, or in the results of the neurosciences (an example of the latter – the property of questimity-declatimity).
Thus, the factors identified in socionics – are not at all random. First, they reproduce absolutely everything already known in psychology before (although not laid into the original Jungian basis, such as - the factor of judiciousness-decisiveness, independently discovered in the BIG FIVE model, and the factor of democratism-aristocratism, independently discovered both in the HEXACO model and in neuroresearch). The new socionic factors additional to this, previously not described in the psychological literature at all, are also, evidently, law-governed. They are, one must think, the most significant for psychological communication – otherwise they would not have found their reflection in the notions of the mass oral socionic culture about the properties of socionic psychotypes, traits and functions.