V. L. Talanov on How and Why the Paths of MBTI and Socionics Diverged, and Why This Made Socionics a Much More Advanced and Substantive Scientific Field
Psychological types (in essence, independent non-overlapping sectors of multidimensional psychological space) gradually became the primary, basic concept in empirical socionics. In socionics they are also most often diagnosed as a whole. In American typology, however, which is very close to socionics in the results of structuring psychological space, this is not at all so, and what is invariably taken as the basis is, on the contrary, not psychotypes but only four basic traits (far from exhausting all the real psychological diversity). These traits — vertness, nality, logic-ethics and intuition-sensing. Each trait represents a hyperplane in psychological space that divides it into two poles; four hyperplanes ultimately divide the space into 16 sectors, each of which received the name of one of the 16 psychotypes.
Both in the works of Carl Gustav Jung and in the early theoretical constructions of the founder of socionics, Aushra Augustinavichiute, such an approach was also used. However, subsequently socionics in Russia, in Ukraine and in a number of other European countries began to rely in the diagnosis of psychological types not on four-factor diagnostic questionnaires but on live expert diagnosis of types in their “integral” expression – accordingly, the properties of the types inevitably came to take into account the whole real diversity of psychological temperaments, and not only its 4 selected dimensions.
For all its obvious minuses from the point of view of the standardization of diagnosis, this “oral” tradition specific to socionics (reminiscent of the gradual accumulation of experience in Chinese folk acupuncture medicine) gave socionics undoubted scientific pluses. The “pluses” in this case consist in the fact that in the emerging socionic culture the most diverse characteristic properties of psychotypes were noted more easily, including those fundamentally new with respect to the four basic traits but manifesting, at least in weak form, at the intersection of the four dichotomies owing to their nonlinear interaction with one another. These properties were studied and not ignored, although they were often an obvious new formation with respect to the semantic content of the four basic diagnostic traits. Thus it was found, for example, that the psychotypes of the second and third quadras differ from the psychotypes of the so-called “peripheral” quadras by a new property, not reducible to the four basic traits, of decisiveness-judiciousness, and accordingly one and the same sensing can behave very differently in “decisive” and in “judicious” psychotypes — in one case as aggressive “force sensing”, in the other case — as “sensing of sensations”, which differs very considerably in its semantic content. Similarly, differences were found between the manifestations of black and white intuition, black and white ethics, black and white logic.
Much was also contributed to this development by the functional approach specific to socionics, with the initial identification of only eight information aspects – but even these eight aspects alone, in order to delimit their content between Ni and Ne, Si and Se, etc., already clearly required the involvement of new concepts besides the mere differences of these functions in their vertness. And the introduction of the 15 Reinin traits and the naturally begun search for their content stimulated even more the process of expanding the number of axes of psychological space on which socionic differences actually rely. In total, the psychotypes of socionics take into account differences along at least six orthogonal psychological factors, including absolutely all the factors of the psychological factor models BIG FIVE and HEXACO, while the MBTI system became frozen on the initial 4 factors originally laid into it – namely, all those personality factors that were known to science by the beginning of the 1950s, by the time MBTI was laid down.
The theoretical models of socionics developed accordingly, absorbing new concepts. This development did not and could not take place in MBTI typology, where the formal rigid restrictions at the “input” of diagnosis did not subsequently allow fundamentally new conclusions to be felt out at the “output”. Unlike typology, socionics, relying not on a four-factor questionnaire but on an oral tradition, for a long time followed the path of empirical “feeling out” of the most objective boundaries between psychological types, that is, being in constant live contact with natural truth, it flexibly formed the optimal boundaries of the sectors in psychological space, not shying away from taking into account, in drawing these boundaries, those newly discovered properties of types that were not directly reducible to differences in vertness, nality, logic-ethics and intuition-sensing.
Is it good that this was so? Yes, very good. The point is that the content of the four basic traits initially used in diagnosis was never “God-given” either, but represented a rough result of those same empirical observations by the founding researchers of the diversity of human manifestations. It does not follow from anywhere, for example, that intuition must manifest itself in the same way in all types of the so-called “intuitive” pole (today we know that in each of the eight types these manifestations are very distinctive), but the initial “rough hypothesis” of the founders, especially beginning with Briggs and Myers, prescribed that intuition, within the framework of this initially “rough hypothesis”, manifest itself in the same way in different types, and the Briggs-Myers diagnosis was also aimed at revealing in types exclusively the common features of their dichotomous pole. Accordingly, in typology the boundaries between types were distorted; they were led away from the places of their natural gravitation. Another example is the axis of nality, which, also being unambiguously fixed in the initial Briggs-Myers diagnostic questionnaires, prescribed to all types the same behavioral manifestations of rationality or irrationality — although today we already know well that the irrationality of intuitives manifests itself not quite in the same way as in sensing types, and in extraverts — not quite in the same way as in introverts (for example, if for the irrationality of extraverts the key point is improvisation, then for introverts such a key point is passivity and laziness, although by and large both manifestations go back to a deficit of evaluative functions and the resulting lack of planning).
Nevertheless, such nuances were consistently ignored in typology, which led to the incorrect drawing of boundaries between types on the basis of arbitrarily chosen “diagnostic” properties, selected purely voluntaristically and fixed in the questionnaires. Thereby any potentially new properties of psychotypes and their groups that were not reducible to the diagnostic questions initially laid into the Myers-Briggs questionnaire were blurred and not revealed in research.
Socionics avoided these shortcomings in its development. And it avoided them – precisely owing to its initial “looseness”, the absence of reliance on canonized questionnaires, which prompted the typers themselves to seek the optimal boundaries between types of people, taking into account not only four randomly chosen axes but all objectively existing axes of the real multidimensional psychological space. As a result, among all existing psychological classifications, the boundaries between the sectors of multidimensional psychological space gradually felt out by the expert “public opinion” of socionics today, apparently, best correspond to the real physiological factors of brain activity that objectively underlie the partition of psychological diversity into psychotypes. The adequacy of the socionic classification is also underscored by the circumstance that it is precisely within the boundaries between types accepted in socionics that new properties are revealed, nonlinearly generated at the intersection of several “basic” traits (proceeding from physiological considerations, it is precisely such generation that one should expect from “correct” models of the structure of psychological space, where not only linear but also U-shaped dependences act between the factors).
(from articles by V. L. Talanov of 2011)