Quantitative Socionics

Where MBTI Falls Short, Compared with Socionics

V. L. Talanov · January 15, 2021 · Original source

(from Ivan Romanov’s comments to the post https://vk.com/wall-168821911_3545 )

“The most important:

  1. The descriptions of the MBTI types are often taken out of thin air and are little connected with the descriptions of the 4 dichotomies forming these types (the example with ESTP, which by socionics came out as an ethical, is especially impressive)

  2. Judicious and decisive features are ascribed to different MBTI types in random order, and these differences are in no way reflected in the 4 dichotomies (here the example with INTJ is already especially telling, which came out vividly decisive, while the socionic LII - is judicious)

  3. The balance of traits is shifted in favor of sensing and ethics (i.e. answers for sensing and ethics in MBTI are more “socially desirable”, and no correction for this is made)

  4. Intuition, irrationality and ethics are correlated just as strongly or even more strongly than in socionics. Because of this, the share of the types INFP, ENFP, ISTJ and ESTJ grows disproportionately (in theory, while in practice, as I already said above, everything there is even worse and more confused). In socionics, let me remind you, such a disproportion is to a considerable extent leveled out due to the influence of judiciousness, correlated with introversion: http://danidin.ucoz.net/index/0-32 and also the influence of weaker traits. Therefore, if socionists try to compose tests on the MBTI scheme, this problem comes out with terrible force: http://socionika-test.info/ru/statistics/

  5. MBTI uses a very confused functional model. And the main problem - imho, is that they themselves cannot figure out what the essence of the ratio-irrationality axis consists of. Actually, Talanov speaks about this in the article above. Rationality - is in general a weaker trait in the basis than the other three. And in MBTI it is additionally tied to sensing. This, in essence, turns the whole difference between quasi-identicals in MBTI into nothing. Whereas in socionics between these types there is - not only rationality (spelled out better than in MBTI), but also judiciousness-decisiveness + other less important, but also significant traits - merriness-seriousness, statics-dynamics, questimity-declatimity, constructivism-emotivism. Therefore determining duality by MBTI - is a bad idea. Of the 7 value traits there is only one there, and even that in a crooked version.

-------------------------

- More on the topic:

On the influence of the additional Reinin traits on the relative numbers of sociotypes and the global symmetry of the socion:
http://danidin.ucoz.net/index/0-41

On the inconsistency of the properties of types in socionics and MBTI and the myth that J/P - is not ratio-irratio, but supposedly statics-dynamics (in fact, no, but INTP in its “classical” MBTI description is indeed closer to LII, whereas INTJ, you won’t believe it… to SLE!):
https://socionic-references.diary.ru/p201787159.htm?oam ”

Click the image or press + / − to zoom · drag to move · Esc to close