Quantitative Socionics

Clusters of Positivism / Negativism

V. L. Talanov · January 28, 2019 · Original sources: 1 , 2

PART 1

POSITIVISM - WHAT KIND OF REININ TRAIT IS THIS ???

Profiles of the clusters of positivism

Cluster No.ILELIISEIESESLELSIIEIEIESEEESIILILIEIEEEIISLILSE
10,46-0,440,390,51-0,44-0,350,12-0,510,45-0,53-0,760,100,360,230,44-0,03
20,13-0,08-0,290,320,100,26-0,14-0,150,00-0,200,070,10-0,470,040,53-0,23
30,000,15-0,150,21-0,140,050,01-0,27-0,03-0,190,100,33-0,070,080,21-0,29
40,13-0,150,150,01-0,470,030,20-0,220,19-0,16-0,020,260,010,270,19-0,42
50,170,00-0,510,15-0,060,10-0,17-0,280,14-0,19-0,020,50-0,15-0,050,240,11
60,050,26-0,12-0,10-0,52-0,130,060,020,09-0,240,060,33-0,040,270,25-0,25
70,13-0,050,080,18-0,280,140,01-0,190,14-0,01-0,130,17-0,340,100,05-0,03
80,06-0,130,230,25-0,200,310,06-0,09-0,13-0,210,140,10-0,230,20-0,11-0,26
90,08-0,19-0,060,12-0,180,22-0,02-0,200,180,16-0,110,07-0,260,100,20-0,11
10-0,010,08-0,290,10-0,190,37-0,01-0,050,030,02-0,060,38-0,060,010,16-0,47
11-0,12-0,250,090,32-0,02-0,18-0,03-0,020,35-0,320,190,14-0,05-0,200,28-0,19
12-0,04-0,230,10-0,20-0,10-0,080,06-0,230,200,24-0,210,120,170,060,51-0,34
13-0,13-0,120,01-0,120,090,160,04-0,22-0,05-0,26-0,110,39-0,080,060,270,10
14-0,12-0,11-0,190,16-0,130,010,090,120,12-0,16-0,080,100,080,330,06-0,28
150,200,07-0,240,02-0,130,14-0,050,020,04-0,270,160,29-0,120,020,13-0,27
16-0,06-0,07-0,380,09-0,040,000,16-0,040,25-0,04-0,150,11-0,130,140,130,02
Cluster mean0,06-0,08-0,070,13-0,170,070,02-0,140,12-0,15-0,060,22-0,090,100,22-0,18

Profiles of the clusters of positivism

Cluster No.ExtraversionIrrationalityStaticsIntuitionJudiciousnessTacticsCarelessnessLogicMerrinessConstructivismYieldingQuestimityDemocracyPositivismProcess
10,1130,127-0,033-0,0560,239-0,0280,044-0,127-0,032-0,0750,037-0,0040,0220,245-0,016
2-0,025-0,008-0,027-0,062-0,006-0,032-0,0110,1100,0200,105-0,061-0,0170,0080,155-0,021
3-0,033-0,009-0,0190,0400,017-0,021-0,0120,051-0,0170,000-0,043-0,0510,0520,107-0,065
4-0,0650,047-0,0190,0590,022-0,0270,049-0,057-0,041-0,034-0,006-0,0290,0510,1590,016
50,073-0,044-0,0040,001-0,0060,002-0,0140,132-0,073-0,002-0,0240,0040,0320,138-0,042
6-0,053-0,022-0,0320,1280,040-0,0740,0150,007-0,059-0,025-0,0520,0300,0410,104-0,002
7-0,026-0,041-0,019-0,0350,017-0,0040,0050,0020,003-0,0180,0230,0080,0660,1160,033
8-0,062-0,021-0,0400,0150,0020,0150,008-0,0110,0640,005-0,002-0,1000,0380,0930,059
9-0,036-0,0210,013-0,067-0,0150,0100,027-0,003-0,0290,0200,0040,0130,0300,1190,013
10-0,034-0,0550,0310,034-0,061-0,0140,0640,032-0,001-0,004-0,072-0,0330,0320,127-0,060
110,0520,087-0,099-0,042-0,013-0,047-0,022-0,017-0,0260,015-0,080-0,0370,0520,072-0,009
12-0,0550,0840,025-0,0400,002-0,0510,096-0,049-0,0920,0030,0110,019-0,0030,077-0,070
13-0,0040,003-0,043-0,023-0,004-0,0510,0170,080-0,038-0,0550,036-0,048-0,0500,076-0,024
140,007-0,0210,0020,052-0,009-0,038-0,012-0,070-0,0210,023-0,044-0,037-0,0350,093-0,011
150,007-0,002-0,0070,073-0,022-0,0230,0180,0730,0040,017-0,057-0,0170,0340,0970,009
160,027-0,0270,006-0,004-0,032-0,014-0,050-0,007-0,0430,005-0,0120,043-0,0300,103-0,026
Cluster mean-0,0070,005-0,0160,0050,011-0,0250,0140,009-0,024-0,001-0,021-0,0160,0210,118-0,013

SUBSTANTIVE PROPERTIES (CLUSTERS) OF POSITIVISM (identified experimentally using questionnaires)

1) AN OPTIMIST; PRIMARILY SEES THE GOOD IN THE SURROUNDINGS, RATHER THAN THE BAD; IS USUALLY SATISFIED WITH WHAT IS PRESENT, HAVING NO OBJECTIONS TO IT (in this cluster, as in the subsequent ones, the questionnaire items after the line have negative rather than positive loadings on the property)
  1. If I were a journalist, I would more often write about the merits of the life around me than about its shortcomings.
  2. Which word is used more often in speech? - 1) Bad 5) Good
  3. I can quickly find an upside for myself even in obvious downsides.
  4. I can find upsides in things in which others find none.
  5. I am more of an optimist than a pessimist.
  6. I enjoy listening to bard songs.
  7. I more often give optimistic than skeptical advice.
  8. I relate to this: “Think well of reality, and it will become what you want it to be.”
  9. I primarily see what connects, unites, and brings people together, rather than what divides their interests.
  10. It can be said of me that I am an internally harmonious person, far removed from any neuroticization or insoluble problems.
  11. I am mostly satisfied with the way the world is organized.
  12. As a rule, I initially see joyful hope where I later find only disappointment.
  13. When starting something, I believe in success and proceed on the assumption that things will certainly not get worse.
  14. My imagination has a joyful rather than an anxious tone.
  15. I consciously try to avoid any unpleasant and disturbing thoughts.
  16. I like most of the people I know.
  17. People say that I have a poor sense of danger and often underestimate dangers.
  18. Most often, I am in a relaxed and bright mood.
  19. Initially, I am more often inclined toward acceptance than rejection.
  20. More harm comes from those who are: 1) Satisfied with everything. 5) Dissatisfied with everything.
  21. Bright joy or joyful illumination - call it what you will - is the usual background of my “daytime” mood.
  22. I am good-natured and satisfied with everything most of the time.

----------------------------------------------------------------------—

  1. Very often, I feel that I am clearly missing something I need in order to feel joy.
  2. I am often ironic in my conversations.
  3. I pay attention to unpleasant bodily sensations (itching, tingling, numbness, vibration, pain, heaviness, etc.) far more often than to pleasant ones.
  4. I am a master at making gloomy predictions.
  5. I am perceptive about other people’s lack of talent and immediately see it through any “mask.”
  6. I often feel a certain inner protest or disagreement.
  7. At times (and not infrequently), I listen closely for something to find fault with.
  8. I have this trait: things are often “not right” for me: the potatoes are too hot, and the oranges are too sour.
  9. True patriotism is most often not pride, but shame and pain for one’s homeland.
  10. I enjoy criticizing.
  11. I often find myself constantly expecting trouble.
  12. I often spend time thinking about possible troubles.
  13. I often feel irritated for no particular reason.
  14. I involuntarily seek situations in which I could frown rather than smile.
  15. Being a skeptic by nature, I am prone to frequent doubts and hesitation and notice all the contradictions and imperfections of the surrounding world.
  16. Sometimes, when talking with friends, I clearly “go overboard” in my critical assessment of other people’s actions.
  17. An elevated level of negative emotions is usual for me.
  18. People can be so repulsive that I often feel like doing something nasty to them.
  19. Sometimes I look for trouble or disappointment where there is none.
  20. The word “cannot” is used in speech more often than the word “can” (this refers to the average speech of the people around you - think about it and assess it).
  21. Very unpleasant ideas and suppositions that promise trouble often come into my mind.
  22. I am more of a skeptic anticipating future troubles than a romantic anticipating future good fortune.
  23. I am easily irritated and often feel dissatisfied with something.
  24. In conversations, I “probe” the other person more for contradictions and disagreement with me than for agreement and shared views.
  25. Most of the time, I am more dissatisfied than satisfied with at least something.
  26. My negative emotions break out more often than my positive ones.
  27. Certain things often cause irritation to build up in me.
  28. Notes of distrust and doubt often slip into my voice.
  29. I often use the words “no,” “never,” “not for anything,” “in no case,” and “under no circumstances” in my speech.
  30. My attention is more often focused on finding shortcomings than merits in something I have just bought.
  31. I always find the object I am studying lacking in useful and good possibilities; its negative possibilities, however - those are immediately apparent.
2) IN POSITIVISTS – A RELATIVELY ENHANCED ABILITY TO PERCEIVE THE SPATIAL GEOMETRIC SHAPES OF OBJECTS (ACCORDINGLY, SLIGHT ADVANTAGES IN APTITUDE FOR ARCHITECTURE, IN PERFORMANCE ON AMTHAUER’S SUBTEST No. 8, ETC.)
  1. I have a particular interest, and perhaps even a talent (apparent or hidden), for architecture and architectural design.
  2. I more often pay attention to the distinctive features of objects’ geometric shapes than to differences and distinctive features in their size.
3) POSITIVISTS SHOW SOME PREDOMINANCE OF RIGHT-HEMISPHERE MOTOR REGIONS (LEFT-HANDEDNESS AND AMBIDEXTERITY OCCUR MORE OFTEN)
  1. I more often hold a paintbrush in my left hand.
  2. I usually open doors with my left hand.
  3. With my left hand, I can draw a circle or square just as neatly as with my right hand, or even better (check this).
4) POSITIVISTS RELATIVELY MORE OFTEN SHOW SOME PREDOMINANCE OF THE RIGHT-HEMISPHERE REGIONS OF THE AUDITORY (HEARING) ANALYZER OVER THE LEFT-HEMISPHERE REGIONS (SENSITIVITY TO SPEECH SOUNDS AND SPEECH PERCEPTION IS REDUCED, WHILE SENSITIVITY TO NON-SPEECH NATURAL SOUNDS IS ENHANCED).
  1. I have difficulty learning and remembering verbal material - poems, surnames, first names, telephone numbers, etc.
  2. I usually hold the telephone receiver to my left ear.
  3. How often do you listen to music on your own initiative (while working or resting)? 1) No more than 10 times a year 2) On average, once every week or two 3) On average, once every two to four days 4) Almost daily 5) Practically daily and, moreover, for an average of at least two hours a day
  4. I often forget and mix up people’s names.
  5. I prefer to listen to music only through stereo systems - otherwise, it is not music at all.
  6. It would be easier for me to express love through music than through words.
  7. I have a very good memory for people’s voices.
  8. I hear even very faint sounds that other people neither hear nor notice.
  9. I find it difficult to say tongue twisters - when repeating one several times quickly, I am bound to stumble at least once (“there is grass in the yard, and firewood on the grass”).
  10. Sometimes I struggle to recall the word I need - in such cases, a prompt always helps.
  11. I find it difficult to think of synonyms for a word (that is, to retrieve other words with a similar meaning from memory).
  12. If I speak quickly, my speech comes out fluent but confused, sometimes with meaningless insertions, because I find it difficult to monitor my own speech.

--------------------------------------------------------------------—

  1. In a poem, the content is more important to me than its “musical intonation.”
  2. Since childhood, I have remembered a great many theorems, rules, and poems from school.
5) DESPITE GREATER DOMINANCE OF THE RIGHT-HEMISPHERE AUDITORY REGION, POSITIVISTS HAVE RELATIVELY REDUCED SENSITIVITY TO PITCH, INCLUDING THE ABILITY TO REMEMBER AND DISTINGUISH TIMBRE, AS WELL AS TO REMEMBER MELODIES (NEGATIVISTS ARE SLIGHTLY BETTER AT ALL THIS, AND POSITIVISTS - SLIGHTLY WORSE)
  1. I like rap music more than blues or country music.

------------------------------------------------------—

  1. I have a good memory for any complex musical melodies.
  2. I am sensitive to, and have a good memory for, the timbre of voices or musical instruments.
  3. It is true that I almost never make a mistake about the pitch of a musical note and can easily reproduce the sound of the required note with my voice or in my mental imagination.
6) POSITIVISTS TEND TO HAVE A SOMEWHAT WEAKER ABILITY TO PERCEIVE AND REPRODUCE RHYTHMIC SEQUENCES THAN NEGATIVISTS
  1. I have problems distinguishing or repeating different rhythmic sequences that have just been tapped out - it would probably be difficult for me to learn to recognize even slow “Morse code” by ear.

-----------------------------------------------------------—

  1. I can easily distinguish one rhythmic sequence tapped out with the fingers or on a drum from another, similar one.
7) POSITIVISTS ARE LIKELY TO TEND TOWARD SOMEWHAT ELEVATED VASOPRESSIN (ANTIDIURETIC HORMONE) ACTIVITY
  1. I usually drink water, tea, or mineral water only during meals, and even then not much; outside mealtimes, I drink rarely and little.
  2. My face is usually puffy, as if swollen.

------------------------------------------------------------—

  1. Passing large amounts of urine is usual for me.
8) POSITIVISTS TEND TO HAVE A SLIGHTLY REDUCED NEED FOR SALT INTAKE (THEY EAT SALTY FOODS LESS OFTEN THAN NEGATIVISTS)
  1. I probably consume less salt with my food each day than other people do - I rarely eat salty foods.

------------------------------------------------------------—

  1. I like all sorts of salted and pickled foods and eat them often and in fairly large quantities (herring, pickled cucumbers, sauerkraut, salted mushrooms, etc.).
9) WHEN RECEIVING INFORMATION - POSITIVISTS SHOW A TENDENCY FOR THE VISUAL ANALYZER TO DOMINATE OVER THE AUDITORY ANALYZER
  1. Which of your sense organs works better, in the sense that the quality of its functioning falls less short of the level of your peers? 1) Hearing 5) Vision
  2. For me, it is almost always better to read something with my own eyes than to hear it with my ears.

-----------------------------------------------------------—

  1. What first appears in your imagination at the word “birds”? IMAGINE IT before reading further! HAVE YOU IMAGINED IT? If you first imagined a visual image of them, enter “1.” If you first heard their voices or cries, enter “5.”
  2. I had strabismus as a child.
10) A POSITIVIST HAS A STATISTICAL TENDENCY TO HAVE BEEN BORN INTO A FAMILY IN WHICH THEY WERE THE OLDEST (FIRSTBORN) OF ALL THE CHILDREN, RATHER THAN THE YOUNGEST
  1. How many other children in the family in which you were raised were younger than you? - 1) None 2) One 3) Two 4) Three 5) Four or more

---------------------------------------------------------—

  1. How many other children in the family in which you were raised were older than you? - 1) None 2) One 3) Two 4) Three 5) Four or more
11) TESTS OF HEMISPHERIC ASYMMETRY - AS A STATISTICAL TENDENCY, POSITIVISTS BREATHE MORE FREELY THROUGH THE LEFT NOSTRIL THAN THE RIGHT MOST OF THE TIME
12) TESTS OF HEMISPHERIC ASYMMETRY - AS A STATISTICAL TENDENCY, IN THE “APPLAUSE” TEST, POSITIVISTS STRIKE THE LEFT PALM FROM ABOVE WITH THE RIGHT PALM
13) TESTS OF HEMISPHERIC ASYMMETRY - AS A STATISTICAL TENDENCY, POSITIVISTS’ RIGHT PALM IS MORE SENSITIVE TO PINPRICKS THAN THEIR LEFT
14) TESTS OF HEMISPHERIC ASYMMETRY - AS A STATISTICAL TENDENCY, WHEN TURNING AROUND, POSITIVISTS MORE OFTEN TURN THEIR BODY TO THE RIGHT, CLOCKWISE
15) TESTS OF HEMISPHERIC ASYMMETRY - AS A STATISTICAL TENDENCY, IN THE NAPOLEON POSE, POSITIVISTS’ LEFT ARM IS FARTHER FROM THE CHEST THAN THE RIGHT
16) TESTS OF HEMISPHERIC ASYMMETRY - AS A STATISTICAL TENDENCY, IN THE “INTERLOCKED FINGERS” TEST, POSITIVISTS MORE OFTEN HAVE THE LEFT THUMB ON TOP

===================

Thus, the positivism-negativism trait turns out to be very closely associated with interhemispheric asymmetry. In positivists, there is an increase in the activity of functions responsible for mood in the anterior (frontoparietal) regions of the left cerebral cortex (compared with the anterior regions of the right hemisphere, the anterior regions of the left hemisphere provide a considerably more optimistic and trouble-free background mood, insensitive to shortcomings in something). Accordingly, speech and motor functions are partially displaced from the anterior regions of the left hemisphere to the right hemisphere.

As for the posterior cortical regions (temporal and occipital), positivists, by contrast, show additional activation of their normal functions (elementary, nonverbal hearing and expanded visual functions).

We advise you to test yourself using the tests of hemispheric asymmetry (clusters 11-16). Check how many tests indicate the positivist pole for you, and how many – the negativist pole. For the author (V. L. Talanov), 5 of the 6 tests listed indicate his own negativist pole.

PART 2

NEGATIVISM:

  1. I always find the object I am studying lacking in useful and good possibilities; its negative possibilities, however - those are immediately apparent. -0,61
  2. Most of the time, I am more dissatisfied than satisfied with at least something. -0,58
  3. An elevated level of negative emotions is usual for me. -0,57
  4. I am more of a skeptic anticipating future troubles than a romantic anticipating future good fortune. -0,57
  5. I feel anger more often than merriment. -0,51
  6. My negative emotions break out more often than my positive ones. -0,49
  7. I often find myself constantly expecting trouble. -0,48
  8. Which is more characteristic of you? - 1) I know how to enjoy conveniences 5) I often pay attention to existing inconveniences -0,47
  9. I reflect on human shortcomings more often than on human merits. -0,46
  10. I clearly lack optimism in life. -0,46
  11. Being a skeptic by nature, I am prone to frequent doubts and hesitation and notice all the contradictions and imperfections of the surrounding world. -0,46
  12. I am a master at making gloomy predictions. -0,44
  13. I am not very sensitive to the sweet lures of winning and good fortune that a given situation promises; I pay more attention to the danger of losing and punishment. -0,44
  14. I often feel that the people around me have wronged me. -0,43
  15. My attention is more often focused on finding shortcomings than merits in something I have just bought. -0,42
  16. I frequently experience depressive states in which everything seems gloomy and hopeless. -0,40
  17. I often feel vexed and disappointed. -0,39
  18. I often feel disgust - almost every day, for one reason or another. -0,38
  19. I enjoy criticizing. -0,37
  20. I often express dissatisfaction with something. -0,36
  21. I often expect some kind of catch from reality. -0,35
  22. I often use the words “no,” “never,” “not for anything,” “in no case,” and “under no circumstances” in my speech. -0,35
  23. There are quite a few people among my acquaintances to whom I periodically point out that they are trying to manipulate me and others through ethics. -0,35
  24. Criticizing other people’s views and statements is always pleasant for me. -0,34
  25. It is usually easy for me to tell whether another person is telling the truth or lying. -0,34
  26. I often spend time thinking about possible troubles. -0,34
  27. I more often try not to raise another person’s enthusiasm, but, on the contrary, to “bring it down” or even ridicule it. -0,34
  28. I cannot stand people who are always “marching in step.” -0,34
  29. Very unpleasant ideas and suppositions that promise trouble often come into my mind. -0,33
  30. I often feel worried and tense. -0,33
  31. When starting something, I prepare myself in advance for problems soon to come and for a bitter struggle. -0,33
  32. I always think about my work in terms of what criticisms could be leveled at it. -0,32
  33. I often express my dissatisfaction with those close to me aloud, for one reason or another. -0,31
  34. I think I have more ill-wishers than friends. -0,31
  35. I quickly and perceptively see all the weaknesses and shortcomings in any person. -0,31
  36. I notice shortcomings and imperfections in things sooner than other people do, and want to correct them. -0,31
  37. I pay attention to unpleasant bodily sensations (itching, tingling, numbness, vibration, pain, heaviness, etc.) far more often than to pleasant ones. -0,30
  38. I suffer from heat more than other people do - I would rather have cold weather. -0,30
  39. I tolerate hot weather very poorly (probably worse than many others). -0,30
  40. I am perceptive about human shortcomings and often pay attention to them. -0,30
  41. I always have a very clear sense of the boundary between myself and the surrounding world, my own thoughts and those of others, myself and other people. -0,29
  42. The world is getting worse every day. -0,29
  43. I can instantly see and detect hidden danger. -0,29
  44. I cling to past grievances (for a long time, I remember only HIS, HER, THEIR mistakes). -0,28
  45. I am very rarely completely satisfied with the quality of what has been done. -0,28
  46. I think a great deal about intrigues in my social circle. -0,28
  47. I can call any action into question and see its weaknesses (I often surpass others in this). -0,28
  48. If my friends are frightened, I usually understand this immediately, although I do not share their fear. -0,28
  49. Troubles greatly lower my mood. -0,28
  50. I like drawing attention to someone’s mistakes and arguing with them. -0,27
  51. I like publicly rubbing the nose of a person with a formally higher status in their mistakes. -0,27
  52. I take a very long time to get over anger, recovering slowly - another person’s remorse and apologies are not enough here; I also need to be left completely alone for a long time afterward. -0,27
  53. I have often been plagued by obsessive suspicions and anxieties. -0,27
  54. Unexpected finds more often evoke tense apprehension in me than anticipation of joy. -0,27
  55. The role of a critic would suit me better than that of a mediator and arbiter. -0,26
  56. I like mentally identifying the sources of mistakes and misconceptions in people I know. -0,25
  57. With my thought and gaze (whether outward or inward), I constantly and intently “probe” the situation. -0,25
  58. By listening, I quickly and unerringly catch all the thoughts that the other person is trying to cram into their speech. -0,25
  59. My favorite activity is to “expose” coincidences by seeking out the barely noticeable regularities behind them. -0,24
  60. I often suspect some kind of catch if everything is going too smoothly and perfectly. -0,24
  61. It is useless to put pressure on me through emotions - it will only elicit my disrespect. -0,23
  62. I detect shifts toward a more negative mood in my partner more easily and observantly than shifts toward a more joyful, more positive mood. -0,23
  63. The word “cannot” is used in speech more often than the word “can” (this refers to the average speech of the people around you - think about it and assess it). -0,21
  64. I often do not get enough sleep. -0,21

Note several important differences between this list and the previously presented list of items on Questimity.

  • Many items on Questimity did perfectly well without the word “often” - for them, even a single occurrence is sufficient. For items on negativism, however, the word “often” turns out to be almost obligatory in the wording of the items.
  • The items on Questimity hardly dealt at all with predictions about the future and the outcomes of undertakings. In the items on negativism, however, this is precisely the primary concern.

Click the image or press + / − to zoom · drag to move · Esc to close