Socionic Theory Taken Seriously - New Developments in Theory and Hypotheses
Danidin (Ivan Romanov) - ON THE VALUES OF DUAL PAIRS.
(March 2, 2019, see the author’s site http://danidin.ucoz.net/index/0-50 and the posts on the socioforum)
Danidin’s text from the socioforum (http://www.socioforum.su/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=75268 ):
«In this work one hypothesis is formulated, which came to my mind on February 21 of this year - as the result of reflections on what, after all, distinguishes the values in the pairs of Alpha and Delta rationals.
The problems that this hypothesis of mine touches on and explains:
- why the poles of the dyadic values in duals must coincide, while the poles of the individual ones - must differ;
- what the true meaning is of the weak value RTs carefreeness, yielding and rightness(“process”);
- how to explain in three words the values of each of the 8 dyads;
- why the supervision rings are turned in the known direction, and not in the opposite one - how to explain this without switching to the language of functions.
In essence, the answers to all these questions have always lain on the surface. The main thing was to look at them from the right side. From the purely biological one. For what is duality needed for above all? For creating a family. And what is the main function of the family? The birth and upbringing of offspring. And after that come the variants of interaction with this offspring. Which is what the article is about.
A brief, condensed content of the work.
Social evolution rests on 4 whales:
A intragroup cooperation and altruism
B intragroup competition for resources
C intergroup competition for resources
D intergroup cooperation (exchange of ideas, resources, genes between different groups).
The carriers of each of the 4 indicated programs in a group are the types that have, respectively:
A vulnerable Se and Ni (rationality+peripherality+farsightedness)
B program Se and Ni (irrationality+centrality+farsightedness)
C vulnerable Si and Ne (rationality+centrality+carefreeness)
D program Si and Ne (irrationality+peripherality+carefreeness)
The rings of benefit and supervision in the socion are directed the same way, namely: A<B<C<D<A (where the link that stands to the right of the sign < , is the supervising one).
This is equivalent to the following:
- Within a separate group, altruists-cooperators always (in statistical tendency) lose to egoists-manipulators (A<B)
- However, intergroup selection weeds out those groups in which egoists have become too many to maintain effective social institutions (B<C)
- Further, between different groups, those that invariably prefer war to peace lose, over long stretches of time, to the more flexible ones, inclined to find common interest with opponents (C<D)
- Finally, groups practicing strong intergroup altruism become too dispersed and are gradually replaced at the individual level by those who prefer to care only about their own (D<A).
The direction in time (relative to the change of generations) is given to these processes by the value traits that relate already to the logical and ethical functions.
Ascending values consist in the subject or group being directed toward its personal future and doing everything to bring it closer - even at the cost of destroying its past. Descending ones, on the contrary, are connected with the subject or group wanting to fix, to preserve its past, even at the cost of destroying its future.
The future of a subject and of a group - is, above all, its children (descendants), the past - its parents (ancestors). The fixation on the ascending strategy in the obstinate (with inert Ti and Fe) is the priority of questions of what to do with children, and the fixation on the descending strategy in the yielding (with inert Ti and Fe) - the priority of questions of what to do with parents.
Therefore at the basis of the values of dual pairs lies:
LII+ESE - intragroup altruism toward (their own) children
EII+LSE - intragroup altruism toward (their own) parents
SEE+ILI - intragroup egoism with respect to (their own) children
SLE+IEI - intragroup egoism with respect to (their own) parents
LSI+EIE - intergroup competition in terms of suppressing someone else’s future (the aspirations of other people’s children)
ESI+LIE - intergroup competition in terms of suppressing someone else’s past (the traditions of other people’s parents)
IEE+SLI - intergroup exchange and cooperation in terms of association with someone else’s future (readiness to draw other people’s children into one’s own society)
ILE+SEI - intergroup exchange and cooperation in terms of association with someone else’s past (readiness to be drawn into someone else’s society)
In the left ring of social progress, where everywhere the following quadra supervises, the damage is done to the generation of parents. In the right one, where the preceding one supervises - to the generation of children. The trait of rightness-leftness turns out to be connected with the global direction of the flow of resources in time (regardless of from whom they are taken and to whom they go - to their own or to others): the left take from the past and give to the future, the right - take from the future and give to the past.
Finally, the last dyadic trait, democratism-aristocratism, turns out to be connected with whom the subject prefers more to consider as his own - his ancestors or his descendants. Aristocrats consider their ancestors more as their own, and accordingly turn out to be more strongly tied to the existing hierarchy of seniority, connected with age. Democrats consider their descendants more as their own, therefore they are as if deprived of roots, but on the other hand they think more about the sprouts of their future - for them a more important value is the possibility of raising their offspring independently.
=====================
I also recommend everyone to watch this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AERQrIyk7og
It came out literally the other day, and I saw it literally right after I had posted this work of mine on the site (it happens ).
In it Alexander Markov (a very clever man and a prominent scientist - biologist, paleontologist, popularizer of science), in co-authorship with his son, investigates social processes by means of computer modeling. The dependence of the evolution of the brain, memory and learning abilities on the parameters of intragroup and intergroup selection is considered. I will not hide that I borrowed some general considerations from there (although the goal of that work differs noticeably from mine, the general range of the questions touched on turned out to be surprisingly close to the subject of my article).»