Quantitative Socionics

Socionic Functions and Types from the Standpoint of the Evolutionary Approach. Part 2. Ne

I. Y. Romanov · March 19, 2022 · Original sources: 1 , 2

Now let us talk about the evolutionary role of the Ne function.

The survival and reproduction of the ILE genotype in any population is connected above all with what is customarily called the “founder effect”. Literally - if, owing to an increased striving for novelty (and here ILE has almost no competitors), some individual or narrow group suddenly finds and discovers for itself a new ecological niche, then with a high degree of probability it is precisely the genes of the discoverers that will predominate among the offspring. If the niche is relatively large, then even one successful attempt out of many unsuccessful ones is enough for this effect to work (this is precisely why ILEs generate such an enormous number of ideas - yes, 99% of them are erroneous, and sometimes frankly delirious, but there is always the dream of finding that very treasured 1% that will open the door to a new, shining world not yet mastered by anyone). In human society, the analogue of ecological niches is professional niches. This is precisely why maintaining the scientific and technological progress that creates ever new niches of this kind is a question of physical survival for ILE. In a purely conventional society, living by the notion that there is nothing more beyond its borders, the behavioral strategy of ILE and the genes associated with it are gradually weeded out by selection. In a similar way they are weeded out in nature as well - in endemic populations occupying isolated ranges, we suppose, the ILE element tends to zero over time, whereas with the breaching of any ecological boundaries and the spilling of a population beyond them, it, on the contrary, increases sharply. Analogously, among people too, the genes of pioneers are found more often in new ecological ranges (America, for instance), while in ranges of old settlement (Africa, the Middle East, in Russia - the Central Black Earth region) their percentage is minimal.

The survival strategy of the IEE type is also connected with the novelty effect, but here it is a matter not so much of discovering fundamentally new ecological niches as of establishing inter-niche connections. As in the case of SEE, the creative form of Fi is especially effective in everything connected with sexual selection. However, unlike the black-sensing SEE, who strives for dominance within already established sexual strategies, the black-intuitive IEE goes another way - seeking potential partners where others would not have thought to look. Namely, the author believes that in nature the genetic strategy of IEE is connected first of all with the striving for active interpopulation and even interspecies crossing (which, as is known, can genetically improve the health of closed populations, reducing the danger of the manifestation at the phenotypic level of recessive alleles associated with harmful mutations). The Ne ability to find common ground with a partner who differs maximally from the habitual norm, in combination with the declatim lack of squeamishness toward strong deviations from the norm, makes IEE an ideal intermediary between different subpopulations of one species - initially a genetic one, and with the development of culture - an informational one as well (the talent of a translator from language to language also belongs to the strongest features of IEE).
In societies where the IEE strategy predominates, arbitrarily broad connections with surrounding societies, genetic and cultural, are also approved (and, owing to the white-declatim nature of IEE, the goal here is precisely the preservation of the original society through enrichment by the contribution of its neighbors, and by no means its dilution and destruction). On the contrary, where the IEE line is displaced, reproductive and cultural isolation is encouraged.

As for the conflictors of the two types discussed above, their genetic reproduction strategies are conservative and are connected with different forms of genetic isolationism.

Here, in our view, one should especially emphasize the important evolutionary role played by the trait of questimity. Thus, owing to its striving to distance itself from other individuals of its species, questimity is responsible for any form of directional selection - selection in which the advantage goes precisely to extreme, divergent individuals. For example, the genes of ILE, largely precisely owing to their linkage with questimity, tend to migrate, running away from the original central range of the population into newly discovered peripheral ones. Which often ultimately leads to new speciation.
Let us note that in this case the main cause of speciation is a change in the objective conditions of the external environment. However, ESI is also a questim type - but at the same time one that denies the contribution of Ne, that is, denies novelty. How, then, is the questimity of ESI realized?

The genes of ESI, owing to the same questimity, separate and set themselves apart within the original range into ever more and more narrowly specific niches. The key mechanism of genetic divergence from the original population here is genetic drift - random wanderings of the genetic norm within the population - which, owing to statistical regularities, are the stronger the smaller its size. As a result of such wanderings, the sexual behavior of individuals changes randomly; it becomes ever more complexly stylized, “ethical” in the socionic sense of this word (i.e. detached from any objective prerequisites) and anti-black-intuitive (when even the slightest deviation from the habitual is already noticed and critically recorded). Ultimately this can lead, and does lead, to reproductive isolation from the original population.
Analogously, in human communities too, the ESI line of behavior is connected with the formation of stylized local features of people’s behavior (rules of “good form”, politeness, etiquette, etc.) that affect the possibility of contacts between them. Violators of such rules are expelled from society, which stabilizes and preserves its structure, protecting it from any uninvited guests from outside. Sexual behavior, since sex is connected with the greatest vulnerability of the personality, is always connected with the maximum number of unwritten rules. Accordingly, it is precisely the genes of ESI that gain the greatest advantage within populations following the path of genetic isolation (all sorts of communities closed in on themselves and hostile to any guests from outside).

Declatimity is connected with tolerance toward other individuals of one’s population, with readiness to be with them in one space and in one ecological chain, and is therefore responsible for the formation of the population norm as a consequence of stabilizing selection.
At the same time, the IEE strategy was designated by us above as forming a broad norm by blurring the rules, by including ever new subjects from outside into the community. The LSI strategy here is directly opposite - the norm is formed narrowly, by tightening any rules and erecting clear, impenetrable boundaries between the social system and the outside world.
It is reasonable to suppose that species and populations in which the genetic and behavioral line of LSI once prevailed arrived at such a state after once passing through the harsh sieve of natural selection. Namely, the environment in which they were formed was at the same time extremely impoverished in opportunities and highly aggressive (it rejected any deviations from the norm, any divergent behavior - both external escape, as in ILE (there was nowhere to run), and internal stylistic separation, as in ESI (because of the constant mixing of the population, it was impossible to isolate oneself locally and create one’s own local features). In a situation where neither external nor internal speciation is possible, and the ecological niche, although narrowly specific, is widely distributed (not ESI endemics), a species is capable of conserving itself in unchanged form for an unlimitedly long period of time. Tadpole shrimps and sharks are precisely such species in which the LSI line once prevailed.

In human culture, selection of this line proceeds especially actively in Eastern tyrannies and societies of the totalitarian type - where the behavior of all their members is strictly regulated, down to the smallest details, from a single center, and the possibility of isolating oneself or escaping is suppressed physically. All the institutions that presuppose unconditional subordination to the statute and the will of the authorities work toward the reproduction of LSI behavior - army structures, the police, the penitentiary system (prisons, penal colonies, closed medical and educational institutions). Ultimately, any state, as an apparatus of suppression dominating a strictly limited area of land and regulating the movement of people on it, is an LSI structure. (There are three differences between LSI structures and ESI structures here: the latter are predisposed to isolation rather than expansion; they more readily squeeze unsuitable people out of themselves than let new ones in from outside, whereas LSI structures do the opposite; they are not inclined to periodic “mixing” of people locally so that they do not have time to form private connections and thus cannot oppose anything to the dictate of the central authority - ESI, unlike LSI, as “serious” ethicals, strive to strengthen close connections between people). On the whole, the more state regulation, handed down from a single center, there is in the life of society, and the more atomized society is at the same time (i.e. the closer the social system is to the totalitarian one), the more strongly selection in the given population favors the reproduction of the LSI type, which it does, in turn reproducing despotic and totalitarian structures in society.

===Socionic Functions and Types from the Standpoint of the Evolutionary Approach. Part 3. Si.===

A feature of all dynamic functions (and Si is no exception here) that distinguishes them from static functions is that the most critical component of existence here is not the way of spreading one’s genes in the environment but the way of obtaining the resources that ensure the existence of the biological body.
Accordingly, the inertness of dynamic functions in dynamic types is connected with the unconditional choice of one or another strategy of providing resources from among the many possible ones.

The strength of Si, as a sensing function, is responsible here above all for the specifics of the reproduction and consumption of the material resource.
Strong inert Si strives to integrate into biocenoses that are maximally closed in on themselves and stable in their unhurried dynamics, approaching a situation of homeostasis. Within such biocenoses the material resource constantly reproduces itself in an endless cycle of repetitions, in which each next stage does not differ in any way - neither qualitatively nor quantitatively - from the previous one. Time in such systems is cyclical on large scales, and their members live literally within one cycle (“from sowing to sowing”, “from paycheck to paycheck” or even, if this proves possible, “from lunch to lunch”), not thinking about what happens over intervals of time longer than the length of one cycle. In fact, the very category of time regresses and disappears here - time as a measurable duration remains only within the boundaries of one cycle, while everything that happens outside it loses its meaning for the one who lives there.
Let us recall that it is precisely the absence of notions about the distant past and, especially, the future*, the concentration of attention on the current moment of the present, to the point that even thoughts themselves about distant times become impossible (as if an impenetrable veil lay over the future), that is one of the most important markers of strong Si.
* - above all about the future, since traces of the past can still be observed around oneself here and now, in the moment of the present
In a situation where nothing in the surrounding world changes qualitatively over time, the very necessity of planning anything and straining one’s forces in order to change the situation is lost. On the contrary, life in relaxation, without any attempts to leave one’s comfort zone, leads to gradual cocooning in it, thereby forming a homeostasis of the reproduction of the means needed to maintain this life.
Generations change, but people remain the same in spirit; old houses collapse, but the same new ones are built; food is eaten, and then the waste turns into fertilizer in the fields where new food grows. Such is the world in which Si once prevailed (and we will not say that this is entirely fantasy - although modern humanity, living in a time of exponential growth, is infinitely far from such a state, this does not at all mean that it was not like this once long ago and that it will not one day return to such a state).

The difference between the strategies of SEI and SLI is connected with the ways in which the homeostasis of the system of resource reproduction is ensured.
SEI, as an ethical and declatim type, prefers to achieve homeostasis through symbiotic fusion and the mutual satisfaction of the needs of all subjects included in the biocenosis. Literally, the body or even the waste of the life cycle of some beings is food for others, third ones consume the biomass left from the second, and the first feed on what the third leave behind. Thus, it can be said that of all psychotypes SEI is the closest to original nature, where everything is arranged precisely this way. And indeed, it is precisely SEIs who discover in themselves the greatest striving among all psychotypes for participation in natural processes - they like to communicate with animals and to fuss with plants, and like to take care of people in those aspects in which their natural essence manifests itself. As in declatims, there is no squeamishness in them toward everything natural; as in ethicals, there is the ability to understand other subjects, their needs, even if those belong to other species. In terms of ideas, SEI is distinguished by the highest tolerance and conformity in the socion, for they, as no one else, see clearly that everything in this world is bodily interconnected at some level and, in essence, everything goes through one and the same life cycle, albeit in different forms. In the world of SEI everything has the right to life, and nothing can be discarded; there is a meaning in everything, and SEI strives to understand this meaning - thereby being an intellectually active type, despite belonging to the group of the socials (which not infrequently causes surprise among primitively thinking socionists).

SLI, as a logical type, strives to provide for his vital needs as much as possible himself, skillfully applying the tools he has, and at the same time distancing himself from other subjects, whose vital manifestations arouse in him, as a questim, a feeling of squeamishness.
Self-preservation through the achievement of self-sufficiency - these are the key words characterizing the life aspirations of SLI. He is even less interested than SEI in the changes taking place in the big world; he is even further from everything globally political, even more focused on everyday life and on pleasures from habitual things.
If from the point of view of SEI the world is an endless, unhurriedly living village in which everyone is connected with each other through some number of handshakes, then the world of SLI is a multitude of separate farmsteads whose inhabitants are busy with their personal households and do not even want to think that somewhere there is someone else as well.
Having isolated himself from other people, SLI does not see their sufferings and deaths, and does not think about his own future - which allows him to remain a positivist.
The life of SLI is the development of tools that will allow him to produce everything necessary for life while contacting the outside world minimally. In this striving of theirs, SLIs not infrequently achieve mastery and create unique things with little effort (which can subsequently be replicated by other, more dexterous and lively subjects). In this respect SLI, despite the striving of his Si to freeze the status quo in everything, is a type that initiates progress (like the other peripheral logical questims).

Si that is inert in its weakness gives rise to a diametrically opposite style of reproduction and consumption of the material resource. The key element that gives an understanding of this style is the concept of [ecological] catastrophe.
In a world where Si predominates, for an indefinitely long period of time (indefinitely, since in such a world time is literally not recorded) nothing qualitatively happens. But starting from some definite moment, one of the chains of resource reproduction opens slightly. Some resource ceases to participate in the general circulation and begins to be deposited in the form of a mass that no one uses. This remains unnoticed by anyone for a very, very long time, and all this time the resource accumulates and accumulates. In parallel, most likely owing to such a “leak”, the overall volume of the circulation of matter in the given ecosystem also begins to decrease gradually. This, too, goes unnoticed by anyone for a very long time. However, from a certain moment the changes begin to tell - quantity turns into quality. The consumers most sensitive to the presence of particular resources stop receiving the resource necessary for their existence. As a consequence, this evolutionary line begins either to die out or to adapt to the existing changes, restructuring its bodily structure. In any case, at this moment the ecological system is already openly passing from a homeostatic state to a nonequilibrium one, and the course of time is launched in it.
The closed ecological chains begin to open one after another; symbiotic systems collapse. Those species that achieved stability through maximal self-sufficiency also lose stability - after all, this usually requires access to a large number of resources at once, some of which may be rare. From a certain moment the destruction of ecological chains takes on an avalanche-like character; they become ever shorter, to the point that some species switch entirely to the consumption of non-renewable resources. It is precisely the reproduction strategies of such species that should be called, in the full sense, the strategies of weak inert Si.
Time flows ever faster, and the system goes haywire. Everything loses stability, and, conversely, the role of random factors, external and internal, increases many times over. Populations and species that have failed to find a replacement for the resources that have completely dropped out of the ecological circulation die out. On the other hand, among the many species spurred to accelerated evolution by the ongoing changes, some accidentally discover and gain access to the resource that throughout the entire preceding period had been deposited and lay as dead weight, unclaimed by anyone. It is precisely they who turn out to be the main beneficiaries of what has happened; their numbers increase exponentially and many times over. It is precisely their descendants who turn out to be the leaders of the newly emerging, now fundamentally new ecological system that replaces the old one.
Gradually the entire system is rebuilt on new principles. The victorious species give rise to a new diversity. The ecological chains again begin to lengthen and to loop. Time slows down, and the system passes to a new period of stable reproduction.

So, all strategies of vital reproduction that bet on catastrophes are equivalent to weak inert Si. The scale and nature of the catastrophes may be completely different. Here one should include both the global ecological shifts of the past (the “oxygen catastrophe” of the ancient Earth, which made possible the existence of multicellular organisms; the falls of large meteorites that led to mass extinctions; trap eruptions); more local abrupt climate changes; tsunamis, earthquakes, forest fires, even annual floods or rains in deserts - if we are talking about creatures whose life cycle is measured in weeks).
It must be acknowledged that the whole of human history as well, from the time of the end of the last glaciation to the present day, represents by all parameters an obvious catastrophe for the Earth’s biosphere as a whole, while humanity as a species is the main driving factor here - which allows us to judge its integral species type as EIE/LIE. Moreover, if we judge the intensity of the phase transition of the biosphere between the conventionally pre-human and post-human states by the rate of growth of the numbers of the initiating species, then we here and now are practically at the very peak of the changes - when they proceed at the greatest speed.

So, the strategy that denies Si is a strategy that bets on catastrophic changes and, moreover, when possible, itself pushes the system toward catastrophe, itself provokes it.
What, then, is the difference between the reproduction strategies of EIE and LIE?

EIE is a type that, in its reproduction, bets on survival and spreading within the OLD ecological system during the period of its catastrophic disintegration.
The EIE strategy is to survive by any means at a time when everything around is collapsing and perishing. To survive by entering a narrow circle that will remain provided with resources even in the hardest time of crisis. Literally, its goal is to expand its representation in the ecological niche through the death of competing strategies in the fire of catastrophe. In this approach all the features of this type are seen as clearly as possible: negativism (counting on the worst, on destruction), and decisiveness (escalating competition for a scarce resource at the moment of catastrophe as an obligatory component of the survival strategy), and Qe aristocratic questimity (betting on one’s own chosenness, on the expulsion, the ejection of competitors from the system), and Fe (survival through drawing ever new participants into what is happening).
Accordingly, if an EIE ends up in power in some society, this with a high degree of probability means a coming war, deprivation, the exile or death of many, after which this society will never be the same again but will transform qualitatively into something fundamentally different, and moreover, most likely, one no longer possessing such strength as before the crisis. That is, the dominance of the EIE line is always suicidal for the system that gave rise to it. Moreover, the EIE himself often walks on the edge of self-destruction, nevertheless hoping that in the approaching fire he will only be burned, while his competitors will burn to the ground. We suppose that such an approach reflects as well as possible the sadomasochistic inclinations inherent in this type.

LIE, like EIE, bets on catastrophe, but strives to take part in the exponential expansion of the NEW ecological system replacing the old one. A crisis gives new opportunities, opens access to previously unclaimed resources - and it is precisely the opening of these opportunities that LIE awaits, in order to be the first, in a race with others like himself, to master the newly opened living space. The LIE strategy is positivist (since it bets on the creation of a new ecotope rather than the destruction of the old one), decisive (since it escalates competitive rivalry and induces overexertion), black-declatim (since it presupposes the formation of a new norm based on the results of the competition), black-logical (since the competition takes the form of creating something objectively useful - new ecological chains, professional niches and connections).
On the whole, it can be said that the LIE line dominates in society after the successful resolution of some crisis, and remains important until the new system, having exhausted the newly opened opportunities, passes into stagnation. And conversely, LIE in leadership accelerates interpersonal competition, but not a direct one, in the form of a forceful clash, but an indirect, economic one - in the form of a market comparison of the products of the labor of all persons participating in the race, as a result of which the most effective creator receives more resources for further development.

Click the image or press + / − to zoom · drag to move · Esc to close