On Refining the Semantics of the Questim–Declatim Functions
There is a problem of precisely aligning the socionic coordinate system with directions in the space of specific personality properties. This concerns all dichotomies (pairs of Reinin traits) that have been studied relatively recently and whose core meaning has therefore not yet been fully clarified. There is particular reason to raise this topic again when a trait that, according to theory, should be complementary manifests itself as a value trait, or vice versa.
Both democracy and questimity, in the current metric, act as value traits.
But this should not be the case. Questimity should serve complementarity, and since it does not, it is time to consider refining the directions of the axes in the system of these two Reinin traits (and, who knows, perhaps also rotating the axes slightly if, for example, it turns out that Qi and Di in reality act as antagonists more often than Qe and De, or vice versa).
I therefore submit for your consideration a brief analytical overview of eight composite personality properties obtained at the intersection of the democracy–aristocracy and questimity–declatimity axes.
| detailed model each description can be obtained by combining the two neighbouring descriptions (check it!) [the list is cyclic: for 8 the neighbours are 7 and 1, for 1 - 8 and 2] | socionics | brief model | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | self-assertion individualism | critical reflection on one's cultural "firmware", rebellion against established authorities (i.e., the authorities of one's own society), awareness of one's true nature, forming one's own opinion and setting personal boundaries | Qi (ILE, LII, SEE, ESI) | separation from one's own | setting personal boundaries |
| 2 | progress liberalism | idealization of the future (every individual is the seed of a new life), intellectualization, study of the world, scientific and social progress - all for the sake of expanding individual freedoms and satisfying individuals' genuine desires and needs | democracy | uniting with outsiders against one's own - traditional communities are destroyed | only personal boundaries exist |
| 3 | all-acceptance globalization | the desire to personally get to know, absorb, and use to one's own advantage all the diversity of the world; mutually beneficial exchange that ignores any cultural prohibitions and taboos as prejudices (i.e., cooperation with representatives of other cultures and social strata) | De (ESE, SEI, LIE, ILI) | uniting with outsiders | blurring of collective boundaries |
| 4 | blurring of boundaries unification | a broad range of what is considered acceptable, low irritability, little squeamishness, readiness to share the use and ownership of anything | declatimity | an attitude toward unification | blurring of boundaries |
| 5 | subordination collectivism | faith in authority and authority figures, accepting their consensus opinion as "our tradition, our culture", as one's own; groupthink; fitting into the social hierarchy / system of collective responsibility | Di (SLE, LSI, IEE, EII) | uniting with one's own | blurring of personal boundaries |
| 6 | tradition conservatism | idealization of the past (of one's ancestral roots), conservatism - all for the sake of preserving "our" socio-cultural community with its customary systems of governance, authorities, traditions, and rituals | aristocracy | uniting with one's own against outsiders - traditional communities are strengthened | only collective boundaries exist |
| 7 | xenophobia protectionism | rejection of the alien that belongs to another culture and/or social stratum (seen as harmful, dirty, "defiling"); more and more taboos; drawing collective boundaries to protect one's own (understood as safe) | Qe (EIE, IEI, LSE, SLI) | separation from outsiders | setting collective boundaries |
| 8 | drawing boundaries separation | a narrow range of what is considered acceptable, high irritability and squeamishness, keeping outsiders away from what one considers one's own | questimity | an attitude toward separation and opposition | setting boundaries |
The dual nature of the functions Qi and De, Qe and Di becomes clear, especially if attention is paid to the concise model in which we have managed to condense as much as possible the meanings contained in the questimity–declatimity block of functions. Specifically:
Di needs Qe because, to unite one’s own, one needs an image of the outsider as an external threat (and if no such threat exists, it is worth inventing one).
Qe needs Di because, to isolate oneself from outsiders, one must create a functioning system of collective self-sufficiency, which is impossible without cohesion among one’s own.
Qi needs De because, to rebel against one’s own, one must first secure someone’s support, and in this case this can only be support from outsiders (yes, often not disinterested).
De needs Qi because, to taste all the diversity of the external, alien world, one must first free oneself from dependence on one’s own, who instill the belief that the outsider’s fruit is forbidden.
The author is interested in the audience’s opinion: given that the complementarity of Qi with De, and Qe with Di, seems quite convincing in this model, what accounts for the absence of actual complementarity on this Reinin trait?
Which model of the questimity–declatimity functions seems more correct to you (that is, one that implies dual complementarity of Qi with De, and Qe with Di)?
Option 1:
Questimity is the establishment of personal boundaries (in the process of rebelling against the authority figures in one’s own society); declatimity is their blurring (in the process of absorbing the opinions of authority figures and accepting them as one’s own).
Aristocracy is the establishment of collective boundaries (out of fear of what is alien and a desire to protect what is familiar and one’s own, perceived as safe); democracy is the blurring of collective boundaries (out of a desire to personally discover and try everything in the world, to obtain the outsider’s desired fruit through exchange, regardless of whether someone considers it forbidden).
Then Qi is when only personal boundaries exist, but no collective ones (a liberal, globalized, open society); Di is when only collective boundaries exist, but no personal ones (a traditional community, closed to the world, that strictly regulates the behavior of its members); Qe is when the maximum number of boundaries with the external world is established and everything extraneous is indignantly rejected; De is when all boundaries are removed, nothing is taboo, and everything is indiscriminately absorbed into oneself.
That is, De is cosmopolitan and can move without resistance between different Di and Qi worlds, remaining successful in Di worlds because of its willingness to accept subordination, and in Qi worlds because of its willingness to cooperate. Qe, by contrast, is endemic and can live only in a world once chosen; moreover, if this is a caste society, it will fear being defiled by something that is taboo for its caste, whereas if it is a free country, it will try to find a personal dietitian, trainer, psychotherapist, etc., and will unwaveringly follow their recommendations.
Option 2:
Questimity is a feeling of indignation that causes the rejection of everything that does not meet narrow criteria of acceptability. Rejection means demarcation, the erection of boundaries; Qi establishes personal boundaries (between oneself and other members of one’s own society), whereas Qe establishes collective ones (between our own and outsiders, between one’s native culture and an outside culture).
Declatimity, by contrast, is omnivorousness and tolerance toward everything in the world, whether humanistic ideas or police violence, diversity or uniformity, freedom or strict subordination, and so on; that is, it is an orientation toward blurring and overcoming any boundaries. Di dissolves personal boundaries (between oneself and other members of one’s own society), giving rise to what is called groupthink, whereas De removes collective boundaries (between our own and outsiders), giving rise to cosmopolitanism.
In such a coordinate system, democracy is the blurring of collective boundaries (globalization) + the establishment of personal ones (individualism), which together yield liberalism. Aristocracy is the blurring of personal boundaries (collectivism) + the establishment of collective ones (protectionism), which together yield conservatism.
Whereas option 1, in my view, is closer to the semantic content of the traits actually used in questionnaires at present, option 2 produces more obvious dual attraction within the block of QD functions:
- To unite one’s own, one needs an image of the outsider as an external threat (and if no such threat exists, it is worth inventing one) = Di needs Qe?
- To isolate oneself from outsiders, one must create a functioning system of collective self-sufficiency, which is impossible without cohesion among one’s own = Qe needs Di?
- To rebel against one’s own, one must first secure someone’s support, and in this case this can only be support from outsiders = Qi needs De?
- To experience all the diversity of the external, alien world, one must first free oneself from dependence on one’s own, who instill the belief that the outsider’s fruit is forbidden = De needs Qi?
Option 1 and option 2 differ only in the angle of rotation of the questimity and democracy trait axes within the system of personality properties associated with the QD functions. Specifically, the angle between them is 45 degrees in this system. In essence, my hypothesis is as follows: could rotating the system into position 2 lead questimity–declatimity to manifest itself as a complementary trait rather than a de facto value trait, as is currently observed?
For readers taking an interest in the topic of questimity–declatimity functions for the first time: